Home > Food > Pasta Tangent

Pasta Tangent

Being a student in a foreign country with food much more pricey than what I’m used to at home (especially meats), I like to eat (relatively) cheap.  Why spend money on food when I can save it and go skydiving over glaciers?

Now, I will admit that I’m a bit of a food snob, so “cheap” to me is going to be entirely different than “cheap” for the college kid that eats Ramen noodles every night.  While I’m not going to pay the outrageous New Zealand prices for chicken (or, if I do, use it very sparingly), I’m fine paying a little more for the nicer brand of pasta and the artisan bread.

Regardless, pasta has become a staple for me these past two months, eating it at least 2 or 3 times a week.  I vary it up quite a bit, though, one day going with a traditional red sauce, the next an Alfredo, and maybe even blend them for a rosy cream sauce).

PastaTonight I was cooking an easy tomato sauce (with onion, garlic, capsicum, and ground meat).  I did what I normally did at the end, adding some of the pasta water to the sauce, and my flatmate questioned me on it.  “Why did you just add the pasta water to the sauce?”

To be honest, I didn’t really know.  I always thought it had to do with getting the flavors to mesh better, and I’d even heard that the starch in the water from the pasta helped to thicken the sauce.  I decided to investigate, and what I found was startling.

I’ve been cooking my pasta, something so simple, wrong all these years.

Fine Cooking has a great list of tips for cooking pasta, which I’ll summarize below:

How to Prepare the Water:

In general, the more water you can use, the better.  I always try and stick with tiny amounts of water so it will boil faster, but that justs makes the pasta crowded.  More water (often 4-5 quarts for a pound) allows the pasta to breath, the starch to dilute and get away from the pasta, and most importantly prevents the pasta from sticking together.

I’ve always added oil to my pasta water to help prevent noodles from sticking, but that too is a fallacy.  While it does help, it also makes the noodles so slippery that the sauce won’t stick to them, and you end up with almost two separate dishes: pasta on one side and sauce on the other.

Finally, you should nearly always salt the water.  Contrary to popular belief, this is not to allow the pasta to cook faster.  (In order to make a substantial difference in the cooking time, you’d have to empty at least half a cup of salt, probably more,  into the water.)  Instead, it’s used to flavor the pasta.  Pasta is much more keen to absorb the flavor of salt while cooking, and you’ll get a much more even flavor this way than waiting until after to salt.  (I’ve often heard “Salty like the sea.”)

pasta sauce

From Flickr user ginnerobot, licensed under the Creative Commons

Cooking the Pasta:

Since we’ve already ruled out oil, what’s the key to prevent pasta from sticking?  Make sure you stir often (especially in the first minute or two).  This is when the pasta is very starchy and the starch hasn’t had a chance to get away from the pasta, and this is when it’s most likely to stick.  If you use plenty of water and stir often, you can easily keep the pasta from sticking.

How long should you cook it?  Well, it really depends on the pasta and your tastes.  Pasta packages usually give a time (usually 6 minutes for very thin pasta and up to 15 for thicker pastas), but that should only be used as a rough guide.  When you’re nearing that time, taste the pasta every minute or so until it’s as done as you like it.  The traditional Italian way is “al dente,” which literally means “to the tooth”–basically cooked until firm but not hard.  Americans generally like their pasta chewier, and even an American who likes al dente pasta would probably find pasta in other parts of the world undercooked.

Combining with the Sauce:

Always remove the pasta from the water as soon as it’s done to prevent it from cooking further, even if the sauce isn’t ready.  (If you need to reheat pasta later, save the pasta water and keep it hot.  Dip the pasta back in the hot water for a few seconds until it gets hot again.)

Don’t rinse the pasta, and preferably add it to the sauce right away.  The quicker after cooking you combine them, the better the pasta will absorb the sauce, turning into one dish instead of two.  Or course, serve shortly thereafter or your pasta will continue to cook and get soggy again.

So What’s the Deal with the Pasta Water?

As it turns out, there’s quite a debate on this.  Fine Cooking, the site that I’ve linked above, suggests to use it to thicken.  On the other hand, Robert Wolke, a food writer for the Washington Post, suggests that there’s not enough starch in the water to make a difference and it will actually thin the sauce.  Wolke’s opinion, however, seems to be more common between (Internet) chefs, and also seems to fit common sense better.  As he says, “There’s nothing special about this hot water; it’s just a handy source of, well, hot water” that can be used to thin the sauce if it’s too thick.  (On the other hand, if the water was heavily salted, it will certainly enhance the flavor of the final dish.)

So what do you think?  Does adding pasta water to sauce make any difference, either positive or negative?

  1. Sarah
    May 11, 2010 at 3:19 pm

    I don’t think I’ve ever in my life added the water to the sauce. I feel like that would make it all watery. I always add salt and never oil, but only because my grandma told me to, not because of some crazy ingrained cooking awesomeness that I had. And… um that’s all I’ve got.

    • May 11, 2010 at 11:05 pm

      You’ve been doing better than I have, I suppose! I never did either until Dave told me to do both. Guess he was right about the salt, at least

  2. Anne
    May 14, 2010 at 9:26 am

    Why would you add pasta water to the sauce? Is this homemade or canned sauce? I’ve always like my sauce really thick so it sounds like a bad idea to me.
    My general theory for pasta has always been boil as much water as possible then dump in some pasta cook it until it tastes good, at which point I usually combine it with the sauce without rinsing. You’ve been the second person recently who said tath I should salt the water though so maybe I should try that next time…
    Also, have you ever tried fresh pasta from Fasta in State College? I got some during finals week and I would highly reccomend it.

    • May 14, 2010 at 10:24 am

      I’ve always done it with both actually; the theory is that if you let some of the water boil off, the starch that is left will help to thicken it up. But, turns out there’s not enough of it anyway.

      And no, I haven’t tried the fresh pasta but I’ve heard it’s excellent. Do they sell it pre-cooked or did you find somewhere to cook it?

  3. Mom
    May 16, 2010 at 1:42 pm

    As your mom, and the person who cooked for you pretty much all your life, I have never added oil to the pasta water or added the pasta water to the sauce. I was wondering where you picked that up until I read your reply to Sarah’s post. I don’t add salt to the water either, because I really don’t add salt to anything (just trying to be healthy!) I used to rinse the pasta, but read it’s better not to so the sauce sticks (just as you said). I’m so glad you’re interested in cooking. Are you going to cook for us when we visit?

    • May 16, 2010 at 1:44 pm

      Nope, you get to cook for me! That’s the beauty of getting my parents to come visit me. You cook for me and buy me stuff! (Kidding of course. Except not really.)

      but PS, I do look forward to seeing you for much more than those reasons =P

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: